Skip to content

A battle over books: Petitioners push to take away LGBTQ titles from Homer Library youngsters’s part


Homer’s Library Advisory Board listened to testimony on over 50 contested youngsters’s books on Nov. 15, 2022. (Desiree Hagen/KBBI)

A standing room-only crowd of greater than 100 individuals packed into Homer’s Metropolis Corridor final week for a marathon assembly of the Library Advisory Board. Round six dozen individuals gave public testimony clocking the assembly at over 4 hours.

On the heart of the talk was whether or not the board ought to uphold a call made by Library Director Dave Berry in early July. At the moment, Berry selected to reject a request from petitioners who wished LGBTQ-themed titles to be moved from the youngsters’s wing to separate sections of the Homer Public Library or eliminated fully.

Madeline Veldstra is a mom and youngsters’s creator who writes beneath the pen title Madeline Hawthorne. She is main the push to relocate or take away the books. In keeping with her group’s petition, they’re focusing on books that “promote transgender ideology, drag queens, homosexuality and different books that are supposed to indoctrinate youngsters in LGBTQ ideologies.”

Veldstra and different group members stated they’re afraid youngsters would possibly inadvertently stumble throughout the “complicated concepts” in these books. Initially her petition from her talked about simply three titles: “Morris Micklewhite and the Tangerine Gown,” “Julian is a Mermaid” and “Two Grooms on a Cake.”

After the group’s request was rejected by Berry in early July, Veldsta and others filed the petition with the town clerk’s workplace to attraction his resolution. And by late October, the group had added 4 dozen extra titles to their checklist. The books are actually being reviewed by the total Library Advisory Board. The seven-member board, which incorporates a further non-voting pupil consultant, has the ultimate resolution on whether or not the books keep or go.

Veldstra’s group additionally created a web-based petition that as of Nov. 21 had nearly 300 signatures. One acquainted title on that petition was District 6 Home Rep. Sarah Vance. A workers member for Vance confirmed to KBBI through e-mail that she had signed the petition. The staffer shared an announcement from Vance which advocated for folks’ rights in schooling:

“As a mother of younger youngsters, I’m a powerful advocate for parental rights,” the written assertion stated. “I signed this petition to relocate books within the library to uphold mother and father [SIC] rights in schooling whereas respecting the varied views of individuals in our group. We must always at all times respect when mother and father have interaction within the schooling of their youngsters!”

A paper model of the group’s petition has a further 300 signatures.

A separate petition in assist of Berry’s resolution and the present library coverage had over 1,000 signatures as of Monday morning, which is sort of twice the quantity of those that need the books eliminated.

Many of the titles Veldstra’s group desires to maneuver current tales with completely different household constructions, like adopted households which have two dads, for instance. Others discuss in regards to the historical past of varied LGBTQ figures like artist Keith Haring or politician Harvey Milk, the primary brazenly homosexual man to be elected to public workplace in California, or point out themes round drag. Different books are extra conceptual, just like the ebook “Purple,” which is a few blue crayon that does not really feel prefer it matches in.

Challenges made by Veldstra’s group on the LGBTQ titles had been unprecedented, in accordance with Berry. He thinks it is the primary time there was a petition like this in Homer.

“Now we have had challenges over quite a lot of subjects, however they’ve at all times been for particular titles, one or two books at a time,” Berry stated. “That is the primary time we have ever had an attraction that was this sweeping.”

Berry stated the Homer Public Library vets its youngsters’s assortment, utilizing widespread sources and requirements that libraries throughout the nation adhere to.

“We undoubtedly search for critiques in our trusted sources,” he stated. “Every little thing that we have now on the checklist right here is often held in plenty of different libraries as properly.”

Berry stated the library has a longtime coverage to help workers and inform the general public on its collection of library supplies. It is referred to as the Assortment Improvement Coverage or CDP.

The CDP adheres to the guiding rules and moral requirements established by the American Library Affiliation, together with a piece on mental freedom. In keeping with this part, the general public library is a useful resource the place “people can study many factors of view and are available to their very own conclusions.”

Relating to youngsters’s materials, it says, “Library supplies is not going to be inhibited by the chance that objects could also be seen by youngsters. Dad and mom who want to restrict or prohibit the studying of their very own youngster ought to personally oversee that kid’s alternative of library supplies.”

Each Berry and former Homer Public Library Director Ann Dixon stated backlash from teams focusing on libraries that present LGBTQ supplies is a development taking place nationwide. Earlier this summer season in Ketchikan, a metropolis council member tried to cancel a drag queen’s storytime on the group’s public library.

At Homer’s Library Advisory Board assembly on Tuesday, feelings had been operating excessive. Those that need the LBGTQ materials to stay within the children’ part outnumbered the petitioners about two to 1. Lots of those that favor segregating the books are mother and father or grandparents involved about what they name “sexual themes” in a few of the titles. Some comparable to Dave Becker evoked Christianity of their justifications.

“I need to tackle the elephant within the room: it is a non secular matter. What you are seeing here’s a non secular struggle,” he stated.

On the extra excessive facet, some petitioners claimed that publicity to the LGBTQ materials will make their youngsters extra prone to be groomed or expertise abuse by pedophiles. Some, like native pastor Nathaniel Jolly, incorrectly in contrast drag queens to pedophiles.

Many social employees, educators and advocates who work with LBGTQ youth, like Mercedes Harness, refuted these claims. Harness is a former library worker and labored as a forensic interviewer for kids who skilled abuse.

“Not one youngster skilled youngster sexual abuse because of a library ebook,” she stated. “Suggesting in any other case is despicable and dangerous to the youngsters and households who expertise trauma.”

Defenders of the library’s coverage emphasised the worth of inclusivity. They stated by singling out or segregating these books to their very own part, the library can be sending a message to LGBTQ patrons that they don’t seem to be welcome.

Lindsay Martin described herself as an LGBTQ ally. She stated she attended the assembly for her pals de ella who’re LGBTQ youth who didn’t need to be singled out or triggered on the assembly. Martin comes from an adopted household and stated she pertains to being completely different.

“I do keep in mind as a child, not discovering books that appeared like me, and wanting so badly to seek out my household within the ebook,” she stated. “I am simply asking you to see that there is a little child someplace in your child’s classroom that feels alone and does not have a ebook that appears like them.”

The Library Advisory Board is about to decide at its subsequent assembly within the new yr. The general public can submit written testimony earlier than the assembly or testify in individual on Jan. 17.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *